The Evolution of Civilizations: An Introduction to Historical Analysis Read & Download Õ 6

Free download × PDF, eBook or Kindle ePUB ä Carroll Quigley

Carroll uigley was a legendary teacher at the Georgetown School of Foreign Service His course on the history of civilization was extraordinary in its scope and in its impact on studentsLike the course The Evolution of Civilizations is a comprehensive and perceptive look at the factors behind the rise and fall of civilizations uigley examines the appl. I'm a sucker for anyone who stresses that all the divisions and categories we define are imaginary and arbitrary and otherwise explicitly delimits the extent of what they are claiming It makes it so much believable as well as impressive when those imaginary and arbitrary categories are so sensible and informative such deep scholarship here it almost made the madness of human history make sense And it was an added bonus to read it during the covid 19 pandemic trying to identify what stage western civilization is in now some 30 40 years after the book was written my guess is Decay

review The Evolution of Civilizations: An Introduction to Historical Analysis

The Evolution of Civilizations An Introduction to Historical AnalysisIcation of scientific method to the social sciences then establishes his historical hypotheses He poses a division of culture into six levels from the abstract to the concrete He then tests those hypotheses by a detailed analysis of five major civilizations the Mesopotamian the Canaanite the Minoan the classical and the Westernuigley defines a civili. Having read Tragedy and Hope by the same author I had high expectations and indeed they were met Anyone with a passing interest in wanting a new perspective regarding the world in which we live and our history needs to give this author a chance Not an easy read in that he makes you stop and think so you will be a better informed person as a result His audience was high functioning so the author challenges the reader with ideas and insights in commensurate fashion uigley is the favorite author of numerous past US Presidents for good reason His revelations and way of analyzing our world lends itself to those wanting a deeper insight into how things work in the context of nations and history

Carroll Quigley ä 6 review

The Evolution of Civilizations: An Introduction to Historical Analysis Read & Download Õ 6 Ç Carroll uigley was a legendary teacher at the Georgetown School of Foreign Service His course on the history of civilization was extraordinary in its scope and in its impact on studentsLike the coursZation as “a producing society with an instrument of expansion” A civilization’s decline is not inevitable but occurs when its instrument of expansion is transformed into an institution that is when social arrangements that meet real social needs are transformed into social institutions serving their own purposes regardless of real social needs. This book was brilliant in many different ways Its notions of why societies succeed and fail rings very true As does its criticisms of the current analysis of the study of history The brilliance of this book is self evident and I highly recommend you read it however there are several issues with the author's analysis His analysis of Classical Civilization is especially perceptive 1He views all civilizational development as self contained as opposed to viewing it as based upon military and political events He views the Carthaginian Aztec and Inca civilizations as destroyed by their own decadence rather than foreigners with much better militaries seizing power killing their ruling classes and settling large numbers of foreigners in which will kill even a healthy civilization2He ignores political effects inside the civilizations He views the West's success as dependent upon Christianity and its philosophic ideals rather than the permanent state of military competition between the European states and between European classes which seems to be the far likely alternative He tries far too hard to fit Europe into his theory creating artificial boundaries between eras of growth and decay I understand viewing the 14th century as a period of decay but the 18th The 18th century was an era of enormous technological intellectual and social progress Also the 20th century was eually an era of immense progress in many fields rather than an era of decay in anything except religion art and philosophy 3His primary examples are from ancient history in which our records are so poor that people can express whatever sentiment they want onto them When Enlightenment philosophers wanted to say government was bad they made obscure tribal peoples without government into saints while ignoring they all actually had the vices of civilization like slavery sexism war and genocide Similar processes took place when the post WW2 archaeologists tried to claim the Mayans or Sumerians were peaceful intellectual societies what they wanted only to discover literal genocide lists and rooms filled with corpses uiggley uses predominantly obscure civilizations like the Canaanites Minoans and Sumerians of which we know practically nothing so he can gerrymander the evidence into fitting his theory I see no evidence of social decline in the either Canaanite or Minoan society before they were conuered by alien societies 4Worst of all this theory in no way accounts for Asian civilizations like China and India that have survived stably and with relatively few changes for 3500 years These have seen nothing like the cycles uiggley describes and he gives this no explanationI think uiggley's theory has application in theory but he overemphasizes its actual descriptive ability I think it is overly multi stepped rather than like a choose your own adventure with multiple choices that allow different results If Roman Civilization had been able to reform in Caesar's time which seems plausible it would break uiggley's model